FAQS

Do you offer custom decorated cookies?

Currently, we are not offering custom cookies on a regular basis. We do offer holiday pre-sales and flash sales on occasion, however. Please check our STORE for what we have available. You are welcome to contact us to see if we have date availability, however, to accommodate your custom order. If our schedule allows it, we are happy to help!

How much are your cookies?

Since all cookies are baked, mixed, designed and decorated just for you we have a base price. Custom cookies (when available) begin at $36 a dozen. (2 dozen minimum) Our average cookie is 3-4″ for this price; with up to 3-4 colors and designs. Mini 1.5- 2″ cookies are available as well. While we steer clear of character sets due to copyright laws, we do design character inspired sets.

All holiday pre-sales come in smaller sizes than custom orders and begin at 1 cookie on up to 1 dozen, depending on what I am offering. All holiday pre-sales are typically posted 2-4 weeks prior to the holiday so feel free to check out our STORE for availability and offerings.

How far in advance should I book a cookie party or special event?

The more notice you can give us the better! It is never too early to get on our schedule. Your cookie party is only booked once the deposit is paid so the sooner we can confirm your date, the sooner I can get you on the calendar.

What flavor are your cookies?

Wendy’s signature cookie is a delicious vanilla almond (no nuts or allergens) sugar cookie with a vanilla royal icing. On occasion, I will add flavoring into the icing such as lemon, orange or a holiday flavor. Other cookie flavors I have available: Chocolate, Funfetti, and Chocolate Chip. Seasonal flavors are available during the fall and winter holidays. The flavors I have available for my pre-orders are shown on the order listing.

How do your cookies come packaged?

To ensure freshness, all cookies are individually wrapped, heat sealed and in a bakery box. Cookies can also be individually bagged and tied with a ribbon for an additional $6 fee per dozen. Holiday pre-orders typically come with a matching tag and ribbon in case it is a gift. Cookies typically stay fresh for up to 2 weeks inside the heat-sealed packaging.

NOTE: NO exchanges or refunds for orders due to the length of time we invest in our cookies preparing them for you.

​Are your cookies nut free?

Yes, we do not allow nuts in our working home bakery kitchen. However, our home is not nut free upstairs. We do offer a gluten-free version in all flavors or our cookies.

Where are you located? Do you deliver?​

Wendy is a home-based baker operating out of her home in Yorkville, IL. All orders must be picked up at her home at a predetermined time (to be arranged at the time of your order). We operate under the home-baked goods ordinance for our county.

Do you ship?

Forget Me Not Cookies operates under the state Cottage Food Laws and County “Home Baked Goods ordinance.

Our COOKIE INGREDIENTS:

Cookies:  flour, butter, sugar, eggs, vanilla, flavor extracts, salt, baking powder
Icing:  confectioners sugar, meringue powder, corn syrup, vanilla, flavor extract, cream of tartar, food gel coloring.
Our regular cookie includes: wheat, dairy, and eggs