welcome to
Forget Me Not Cookies
​​A heartwarming, home-based business where passion meets flavor. The owners craft homemade gourmet cookies with care, using only the finest ingredients. Each cookie is a labor of love, from rich chocolate chip to sea salt caramel, all sold at incredibly budget-friendly prices. The mission is simple: to spread joy through delicious, homemade treats, making sure everyone can experience a little luxury, no matter their budget. It’s a reminder that sweetness can always be within reach.​
Our Inspiration
Honoring Family, Tradition, and Love
Our journey into the cookie business was inspired by my mom. She loved everything I baked and always encouraged me to open my own bakery. Though I doubted myself, her unwavering support gave me the confidence to pursue this dream. Every batch carries a piece of her warmth and belief in me making our business about more than just cookies—it's about family, encouragement, and tradition.
To honor her memory, our logo features a forget-me-not, her favorite flower. It symbolizes the love and support she always gave me, reminding us of the heart behind our business.
Gourmet Cookies
Treat yourself or someone you love to our gourmet cookies! Our delicious, handcrafted cookies make the perfect gift - or a sweet indulgence just for you. Each cookie is just $2.00. As a small cottage bakery, baking from our home, we currently offer a limited selection. Call/text 419.277.7951 to place your order! We also deliver to Toledo and the surrounding areas for a minimal fee of $5.00. Here’s how our cookie orders work:
​
Half dozen (6 cookies): One cookie flavor
One dozen (12 cookies): Choose up to 2 different flavors
Two dozen (24 cookies): Choose up to 4 different flavors
Three dozen (36 cookies): Choose up to 6 different flavors
And so on…We can’t wait to share our cookies with you!
​​​
​
DELECTABLES AT A GLANCE
​
Baklava
Blueberry Muffin
Blueberry Pancake
Body Parts (Halloween)
Brownie Marshmallow
Buckeye Brownie
Butterfinger
Candy Corn (Halloween)
Cap'n Crunchberry
Caramel Apple
Carrot Cake stuffed with Cream Cheese
Cheez-It Peanut Butter
Chocolate Cadbury Egg
Chocolate Cherry Cordial
Chocolate Chip*
*(Plain or stuffed with Nutella or Cookie Butter maybe an Oreo? You Decide)
Chocolate Milkshake
Chocolate Silk Pie
Christmas Crack
Cinnamon Pop Tart
Cinnamon Toast
Cocoa Pebbles
Cookie Butter Stuffed Oreo Chunk
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
Cookies & Cream Stuffed with Oreo
Double Chocolate Reese M & M
Espresso Gingerbread
Fireball
Fried Ice Cream
Galactic Brownie
German Chocolate Cake
Green Goblin (Halloween)
Grinch
Hot Fudge Sundae
Lemon Raspberry
Lucky Charms
Maple Bacon Chocolate Chip
Maple Pecan White Chocolate Chip
Maple Pumpkin
Molten Lava
Monster
Monster Cream Pie
Oatmeal Raisin
Oogie Boogie (Halloween)
Orange Creamsicle
Oreo Mint Chip
Oreo Stuffed Halloween Sprinkle Swirl (Halloween)
Peanut Butter Banana
Peach Cobbler
Peaches & Cream
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip stuffed with Hot Fudge
Peanut Butter & Jelly Swirl
Pecan Pie
Pistachio (Dark or White Chocolate - You decide)
Pistachio Dream
Pistachio Pudding
Pumpkin Trashcan
Red Velvet stuffed with Oreo
RIP (Halloween)
Salted Caramel
S’mores
Strawberry Ice Cream Bar
Strawberry Milkshake
Strawberry Pretzel
Tie-Dye Christmas
Tiramisu Pistachio Cream
Twix Cookie
Valentine Day Crack
White Chocolate Raspberry
Valentine Day Sugar Cookie
​
TO DISCOVER AMAZING DETAILS BEHIND EACH COOKIE,
CLINK ON THE "MENU" LINK AT THE TOP OF THE PAGE.
Why Choose Forget Me Not Cookies?
Affordable Indulgence
At Forget Me Not Cookies, baking isn’t just a business—it’s our passion. As a small, home bakery, we take pride in creating cookies that are thoughtfully made, never mass-produced. Each batch is baked and designed by hand, with love, care, and attention to detail.We believe everyone deserves a little indulgence, which is why our cookies are both gourmet and affordable. We use the best ingredients we can find to craft treats that taste as special as they look, because we believe quality shouldn’t come with a steep price tag.Whether you’re ordering a custom creation or trying one of our scrumptious cookie flavors, we want your experience to feel personal and joyful. We’re constantly dreaming up new ideas to keep our menu fresh, because your happiness is what inspires us to keep baking.At the heart of it all, we love what we do—and we love serving our community. Thank you for supporting our small business. We hope our cookies bring a little extra sweetness to your day.
Address
4220 Hurley Drive
Toledo, Ohio 43614
​
Phone
419-277-7951
